Payer contracting
How to find which payer contracts pay less than Medicare benchmarks
Price each contracted rate at what Medicare would pay for the same service, in your locality, on the same date of service, and divide. That gives a percent of Medicare for every payer and service line. Weight it by your claim volume, compare it with what payers actually paid, and you have a ranked list of contracts to renegotiate.
Why Medicare is the benchmark
Medicare publishes its payment rules and rates, updates them on a fixed calendar, and adjusts them for local wages and costs. That makes it the one common yardstick that every commercial contract can be translated into, whatever structure the contract uses.
Commercial payers usually pay hospitals well above Medicare. RAND's 2024 hospital price study found employer-sponsored plans paid hospitals about 2.5 times what Medicare would have paid on average (2022 data), with wide variation between hospitals and payers. That spread is the point: two payers can sit far apart for the same services, and a contract signed years ago can drift well below where the market is now.
The method, step by step
- Collect every active contract and amendment for each payer and product line (commercial, Medicare Advantage, managed Medicaid). Amendments often hold the rates that actually apply.
- Turn the contract language into a rate matrix: the rate, the method (per diem, case rate, DRG-based, fee schedule, percent of charges) and the codes it applies to (revenue codes, CPT/HCPCS, MS-DRGs).
- Choose a benchmark set of services: your highest-volume and highest-revenue MS-DRGs, outpatient APCs and CPT codes, so the comparison reflects your real mix.
- Price each service at Medicare for your locality and the same date-of-service year: IPPS for inpatient (DRG weight, wage-adjusted base rate), OPPS for outpatient, the physician fee schedule with your GPCI for professional services, plus lab and ASC schedules where relevant.
- Divide the contracted amount by the Medicare amount. Do it per code, then roll up per payer and service line, weighted by your claim volume.
- Add actual payments from your 835 remittances, using allowed amounts (payer paid plus patient responsibility). Contracted percent of Medicare shows what you negotiated; paid percent of Medicare shows what you collect. Once denials and contract terms such as lesser-of or stop-loss are ruled out, the remaining gap points to underpayment rather than a weak contract.
- Rank payers by the revenue at stake and check each contract's renewal and termination-notice dates, so the weakest contracts are reopened first.
Where the numbers usually go wrong
- Percent-of-charges contracts move with your chargemaster, so the percent of Medicare changes every time charges change. Recalculate after each chargemaster update.
- Lesser-of clauses, stop-loss thresholds, carve-outs and outlier provisions change what is really paid. Model them, or the benchmark will flatter the contract.
- Mixing rate periods. Use the Medicare rates in effect on the date of service: inpatient IPPS rates follow the federal fiscal year starting 1 October, while outpatient and physician fee schedules follow the calendar year.
- Leaving out Medicare add-ons such as outliers or teaching and disproportionate-share adjustments without saying so. Pick one convention and apply it to every payer.
- Benchmarking only contract terms. Without remittance data you can find a weak contract but not a payer that ignores a good one.
Ways to do it: spreadsheets, consultants or software
| Approach | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Spreadsheets built in-house | A one-off look at a few payers and top codes | Weeks of manual work, rebuilt every year, hard to audit back to the contract |
| Consultants and actuarial firms (for example Milliman) | A defensible, normalized study before a major negotiation | Typically a point-in-time study per engagement |
| Price-transparency data platforms (for example Turquoise Health, PayerPrice) | Seeing how your rates compare with other hospitals in the market | Published rates are not your contract terms or what you are actually paid |
| Contract management and modeling software (for example PMMC) | Modeling contract terms and expected payment | Setup depends on how many contracts you load and keep current |
| An AI layer on your existing revenue cycle (Nuvae) | Extracting rates from contract PDFs, benchmarking to Medicare continuously and checking every remittance | Needs your contracts and, for paid-versus-contracted, your 835 files |
How Nuvae does this
Nuvae reads your payer contracts and amendments, extracts every rate into a matrix, and links each figure back to the exact page of the source contract. Government rate agents track CMS updates on their published schedules and recalculate the Medicare side automatically, so the commercial rate as a percent of Medicare stays current without manual base-rate entry.
When remittance files are connected, Nuvae estimates the expected payment for each claim line from the contract terms and compares it with what the payer paid, showing the clause so staff can check it. Termination-notice alerts, rolling out now, flag contracts before their renegotiation window closes. The contract side needs no system integration to start, only the contract files.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a good percent of Medicare for a commercial hospital contract?
- There is no single right number. It depends on your market, service mix and leverage. Use your own payer-by-payer spread and local market data as the reference: the outliers on the low side are where renegotiation pays off first.
- Can we benchmark against Medicare without claims data?
- Yes for contracted rates: you only need the contract terms and Medicare rates for your locality. To see what payers actually paid, and to weight the result by real volume, you need 835 remittance and claim data.
- How often should we redo the benchmark?
- At least once a year when Medicare publishes new rates, and whenever a contract, amendment or chargemaster update changes the terms. Software that recalculates on each update removes the annual rebuild.
- Is percent of Medicare the same as underpayment?
- No. Percent of Medicare measures how good the contract is. Underpayment is a payer paying less than the contract says. A hospital can have strong contracts and still be underpaid, so check both.